Difference between revisions of "Chance News 113"

From ChanceWiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Line 29: Line 29:
:[https://www.wired.com/story/pennsylvania-partisan-gerrymandering-experts/ The geeks who put a stop to Pennsylvania's partisan gerrymandering]<br>
:[https://www.wired.com/story/pennsylvania-partisan-gerrymandering-experts/ The geeks who put a stop to Pennsylvania's partisan gerrymandering]<br>
:by Issie Lapowsky, ''Wired'', 20 February 2018
:by Issie Lapowsky, ''Wired'', 20 February 2018
==Approval rating trickery==
https://www.nytimes.com/2018/01/17/us/politics/factcheck-trump-black-americans-support.html Trump Falsely Claims His Approval Among Black Americans Has Doubled]<br>
by Linda Qiu, ''New York Times'', 17 January 2018
==Matching shirts!==
==Matching shirts!==

Revision as of 15:29, 30 July 2018

January 1, 2018 to June 30, 2018


“The court will not rely on extrapolated numbers from tiny samples sizes and otherwise flawed data.”

-- Judge Julie A. Robinson, quoted in: A crusader against voter fraud fails to prove his case, New York Times, 19 June 2018


Statistic of last year

On lawnmowers and terrorists again: the danger of using historical data alone for decision-making
by Norman Fenton, Probability and Law blog,

Fenton's post is based on his short article that criticizes the Royal Statistical Society's International Statistic of the Year (see last issue of Chance News).

Voting maps

A case for math, not ‘gobbledygook,’ in judging partisan voting maps
by Adam Liptak, New York Times, 15 January 2018

Chief Justice John Roberts famously said that proposed statistical measures of partisan gerrymandering struck him as "sociological gobbledygook." But in many cases it is impossible to avoid technical issues, and the Court needs to make informed decisions.

The article cites a report It’s a fact: Supreme Court errors aren’t hard to find (ProPublica, 17 Oct 2017), where we read

The review found an error in a landmark ruling, Shelby County v. Holder, which struck down part of the Voting Rights Act. Chief Justice John Roberts used erroneous data to make claims about comparable rates of voter registration among blacks and whites in six southern states. In another case, Justice Anthony Kennedy falsely claimed that DNA analysis can be used to identify individual suspects in criminal cases with perfect accuracy.

Gerrymandering in Pennsylvania

Michael Posner sent the following link to the Isolated Statisticians list.

The geeks who put a stop to Pennsylvania's partisan gerrymandering
by Issie Lapowsky, Wired, 20 February 2018

Approval rating trickery

https://www.nytimes.com/2018/01/17/us/politics/factcheck-trump-black-americans-support.html Trump Falsely Claims His Approval Among Black Americans Has Doubled]
by Linda Qiu, New York Times, 17 January 2018

Matching shirts!

Leading probability researchers confounded by three coworkers wearing same shirt color on same day
The Onion, 18 January 2018

A lovely spoof on coincidence stories. We read the following breathless quote from "researchers":

We at least have models for something like two people coming to work wearing the same shoes or both getting a haircut the day before, but this is the equivalent of lightning striking in the same place hundreds of times in a row. We’re going to have to go back to the drawing board on probability analysis entirely.

Football decision theory

Force overtime? Or go for the win?
by Jesse Walker, Jane L. Risen, Thomas Gilovich and Richard Thaler , New York Times, 27 February 2018

In the final minutes of a game, teams may be faced with the choice of making a 1-point kick to tie the game, or going for a 2-point conversion that would win. Going for the tie may seem safer, but is it the best strategy?

Misleading statistic

Lies, damned lies, and one very misleading statistic
by Amanda Taub, New York Times, 28 February 2018

What is the basis for a sensational news story alleging 60,000 rapes were committed by United Nations aid workers over the last decade.

The Times contacted Andrew McLeod, a former UN official who extrapolated the startling statistic from a 2017 UN report that found 311 victims of sexual exploitation by peacekeepers over the preceding year. The article traces the reasoning behind McLeod's estimates, but continues

In Mr. MacLeod’s telling, he always intended his memo to be an advocacy statement rather than what he called “peer-reviewed” statistical analysis — essentially a way to say “here is a problem that is very large and very bad” (my phrase), with digits instead of words.

The problem is, that isn’t how journalists use statistics, or how the public consumes them.

The article cites the Parkland school shooting in February as another example where a reported number quickly went viral. After the incident, many news and social media outlets claimed that this was the 18th school shooting of 2018. In fact, as the Washington Post explains, No, there haven’t been 18 school shootings in 2018. That number is flat wrong.

(Mis)interpreting exit polls

The 2016 exit polls led us to misinterpret the 2016 election
by Thomas Edsall, New York Times, 29 March 2018

Cites this record of exit polling data.

Lottery fraud stories

Jo Hardin sent the following article to the Isolated Statisticians e-mail list.

The man who cracked the lottery
by Reid Forgrave, New York Times Magazine, 3 May 2018

The article begins, "When the Iowa Attorney General's office began investigating and unclaimed lottery ticket worth millions, an incredible string of unlikely winners came to light--and a trail that pointed to an inside job."

Jeanne Albert sent a link to a Vermont story in a similar vein:

More than luck? VTDigger investigates big wins on small games.
by Katy Savage, VTDigger.org, 26 April 2018

Hurricane Maria death tolls

Why are the death tolls in Puerto Rico from Hurricane Maria so different?
by Sheri Fink, New York Times, 2 June 2018

Mediterranean diet study, revisited

That huge Mediterranean diet study was flawed. But was it wrong?
by Gina Kolata, New York Times, 13 June 2018

Subtitled: "A highly publicized trial in Spain found that the Mediterranean diet protects against heart disease. Now the original work has been retracted and re-analyzed, with the same result."

The new findings were also discussed on Andrew Gelman's blog About that quasi-retracted study on the Mediterranean diet . . . (15 June 2018), which cites this PLOS blogpost for more details.

Pew Research Center "Decoded"

Decoded is a new resource from the Pew Research Center. As described on the Welcome page:

Pew Research Center’s main website offers plenty in the way of polished reports, data visualizations and interactives. But there are also lots of methodological musings, puzzles and tangles that you would see if you could flip those picture-perfect research products over (metaphorically speaking)... At Decoded, you’ll find blog posts about some paths taken and some narrowly avoided, including experiments that intrigued us but never saw the light of day.

Among the intriguing technical tools you will find here are the following: