A probability problem: Difference between revisions

From ChanceWiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
No edit summary
 
No edit summary
 
(7 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
A student  asked a member of the Dartmouth math department  the following problem:
A Dartmouth student  asked his math teacher Dana Williams if he could solve the following problem:
<blockquote>
QUESTION: We start with n ropes and gather their 2n ends together. <br>
Then we randomly pair the ends and make n joins. Let E(n) <br>
be the expected  number of loops. What is E(n)?
</blockquote>


QUESTION: We start with n ropes and gather their 2n ends together.  
You might  be interested in trying to solve this problem.  You can check your answer [http://www.dartmouth.edu/~chance/forwiki/ropes.pdf here].
Then we randomly pair the ends and make n joins. Let E(n) be the expected
number of loops. What is E(n)?


You might be interested in trying to solve this problem.  You can check your answer here.
DISCUSSION QUESTIONS:
 
(1) There is probably a history to this problem.   If you know a source for it please mention this on the discussion page above.
 
(2) Can you determine the distribution of the number  of loops? If not estimate this by simulation and report you results on the discussion page.

Latest revision as of 15:41, 6 August 2005

A Dartmouth student asked his math teacher Dana Williams if he could solve the following problem:

QUESTION: We start with n ropes and gather their 2n ends together.
Then we randomly pair the ends and make n joins. Let E(n)
be the expected number of loops. What is E(n)?

You might be interested in trying to solve this problem. You can check your answer here.

DISCUSSION QUESTIONS:

(1) There is probably a history to this problem. If you know a source for it please mention this on the discussion page above.

(2) Can you determine the distribution of the number of loops? If not estimate this by simulation and report you results on the discussion page.